The future of shortstop for the Atlanta Braves is a topic that has fans and analysts alike intrigued, and it's a story that's only just beginning.
Let's start with a bold statement: the Braves' decision not to re-sign Dansby Swanson after the 2022 season has had a bigger impact than many realized at the time. Since then, the team has seen a revolving door at shortstop, with eleven different players taking their turn, but none have consistently performed at a league-average level.
But here's where it gets interesting...
For the 2026 season, the Braves have seemingly found a solution with Ha-Seong Kim, who signed a one-year, $20 million deal. He's backed up by the versatile Mauricio Dubón, a two-time Gold Glove winner. However, there's a catch: both players are free agents after this season, leaving the Braves with a potential shortstop dilemma for 2027.
Assuming baseball continues as we know it, who will be manning shortstop for Atlanta in 2027? Let's explore the options.
Kim, a player with a strong desire to prove himself, is an intriguing prospect. After a disappointing 2025 season plagued by injuries and poor performance, he's looking to bounce back and showcase his skills. If he can replicate his 2023 form, where he posted a 107 OPS+ and stole 38 bases, he'll be a highly sought-after free agent next winter.
The question is, will the Braves be able to retain him? With Kim's salary demands potentially exceeding the 'Atlanta Max' of $22 million, it's a tricky situation. The Braves could offer him a qualifying offer, but will that be enough to keep him in Atlanta?
And this is the part most people miss...
An early extension could be the key. While it's rare for Scott Boras-represented players to sign before free agency, it's not impossible. We've seen it with Matt Chapman, who signed a unique deal with the Giants. Could Kim follow a similar path, especially with the looming threat of a lockout and the prospect of playing alongside his good friend Jurickson Profar?
If Kim decides to test the open market, the Braves could turn to Dubón as their new shortstop. While his defensive abilities are solid, the concern lies with his offensive regression. Since becoming a full-time starter in 2023, Dubón's OPS+ has dropped from 97 to 78.
So, what's the solution?
The Braves could look to trade for a shortstop, targeting either a young player on the cusp of free agency or an 'overpaid' veteran in a salary dump. Names like Jeremy Peña, CJ Abrams, and Zach Neto are potential targets, with Peña reportedly shutting down extension talks last summer.
Alternatively, the Braves could look at more established veterans like Corey Seager or Trevor Story, who could provide short-term or long-term salary relief for their respective teams.
But here's a wild idea...
What about Matt McLain of the Cincinnati Reds? With one more season of underperformance, the Reds might be open to trading the versatile speedster. McLain has shown defensive prowess at shortstop and has the speed to be a threat on the basepaths. The only concern is his bat, which hasn't returned to form since his shoulder injury in 2024.
The Braves could also look within their own system, with international free agent John Gil and college draftees Alex Lodise and Cody Miller all potential options. However, it's unlikely any of them will be ready for a starting role in 2027.
So, what's the plan?
The Braves' front office is already thinking ahead, and with good reason. They need to build a competitive roster for 2026 while also extending their window of success. Having a veteran shortstop on the roster in 2027 is crucial for a team with championship aspirations.
The Braves will likely explore all avenues, whether it's free agency or a trade. It's an exciting time for Braves fans, as they wait to see what moves their team makes to secure the future of shortstop.
